In a great number of applications, it is necessary to distribute resources or tasks to agents collaborating with each other in order to maximize the social welfare of the structure they belong to. The question in these cases is how to divide in a fair way the outcome that the structure eventually earns, say money, to the participating agents. The paper faces this issue by focusing on a real-world application: the distribution of funds to Italian research structures and substructures, after a research assessment program (known as VQR) that is currently evaluating the Italian research production over years 2004–2010. A number of desirable properties for any reasonable fair division rule are identified and exemplified for the case-study application. For instance, it is argued that the money distribution should be independent of possible alternative allocations of research products, and it should consider the actual contribution of every researcher to the outcome of the structure (s)he belongs to. Moreover, the whole process starting from the preliminary phase of products selection is dealt with, in order to prevent possible strategic behaviors from researchers that may lead their structure to miss its best possible score in the evaluation process. A fair solution based on the notion of Shapley value is described and analyzed. It turns out that the proposed solution enjoys all the desirable properties of fair division rules, and it could effectively be implemented in the VQR, as well as in related division-rules applications.

Fair division rules for funds distribution: The case of the Italian Research Assessment Program (VQR 2004-2010) / Greco, Gianluigi; Scarcello, Francesco. - In: INTELLIGENZA ARTIFICIALE. - ISSN 1724-8035. - 7:1(2013), pp. 45-56.

Fair division rules for funds distribution: The case of the Italian Research Assessment Program (VQR 2004-2010)

GRECO, Gianluigi;SCARCELLO, Francesco
2013

Abstract

In a great number of applications, it is necessary to distribute resources or tasks to agents collaborating with each other in order to maximize the social welfare of the structure they belong to. The question in these cases is how to divide in a fair way the outcome that the structure eventually earns, say money, to the participating agents. The paper faces this issue by focusing on a real-world application: the distribution of funds to Italian research structures and substructures, after a research assessment program (known as VQR) that is currently evaluating the Italian research production over years 2004–2010. A number of desirable properties for any reasonable fair division rule are identified and exemplified for the case-study application. For instance, it is argued that the money distribution should be independent of possible alternative allocations of research products, and it should consider the actual contribution of every researcher to the outcome of the structure (s)he belongs to. Moreover, the whole process starting from the preliminary phase of products selection is dealt with, in order to prevent possible strategic behaviors from researchers that may lead their structure to miss its best possible score in the evaluation process. A fair solution based on the notion of Shapley value is described and analyzed. It turns out that the proposed solution enjoys all the desirable properties of fair division rules, and it could effectively be implemented in the VQR, as well as in related division-rules applications.
Social choice; coalitional game theory; mechanism design; Shapley value
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.11770/139045
 Attenzione

Attenzione! I dati visualizzati non sono stati sottoposti a validazione da parte dell'ateneo

Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact